Featured herein would be their 60-grain TAP load chambered in .223 Remington. Hornady has been offering their TAP (Tactical Application Police) defensive line for some time now and it has seen success in real-world encounters. This would represent nearly 6 inches of common building material found inside normal interior walls. One model chambers the 5.56mm/.223 Remington round and the other the 9x19mm round. Oct 5, 2012, Stay in the know with the Personal Defense World newsletter, Hellcat RDP: Springfield Unveils New HEX Wasp Red Dot Atop New Pistol, WATCH: Retired Chicago Fireman, Concealed Carrier Killed in Carjacking, Rep. Carolyn Maloney Drops the Mother of All Gun Control Bills, NICS Review Act: Maloney’s Bill Would Weaponize the NICS System, Gun News, Gun Reviews, and Self Defense Tips, You use of this website constitutes and manifests your acceptance of our. Here are a just a few of the similarities and … Read More From a practical, household standpoint, both platforms provide ample accuracy and few felons would want to be shot with either gun. Real-World Test Conditions Step two was to fire the .223 cartridge from Hornady. When fired from my CMMG rifle, this loaded averaged 2,855 FPS (feet per second) over a Shooting Chrony F1 chronograph. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), POF Minuteman: The 10.5-Inch Barreled 5.56mm NATO Pistol, Springfield Hellcat OSP: Carry Pistol Adds Manual Ambi-Safety, Lone Wolf LTD: Glock-Pattern G19-Sized Pistol for Concealed Carry, Blackhawk Stache: New IWB Holster Redefines Deep Concealment Gear, Bianchi Assent: Safariland’s Newest Concealment Holster Fits 250 Pistols, Winchester Defender Line Adds 5.56, 12-gauge & 20-gauge Loads, 82-Year-Old Vietnam Vet Beats Armed Intruder to Death With Shotgun Butt, 12-Year-Old Boy Grabs Gun, Shoots Intruders Who Shot His Grandmother, WATCH: Texas Mom Lays Out Alleged Peeper With Bone-Crushing Tackle, Taurus TX 22 Competition: Red Dot Mounts Directly to New Pistol’s Barrel. This is basically a way Moving on, we found that the 9mm projectile had traveled a full 15 inches into the wax media after passing through the wall façade. In this guide, we’ll give you our picks for the best 9mm ammo for self-defense and range practice. G2 Research vs. Lehigh Defense, vs. PolyCase, vs. Barnes Bullets vs. Underwood Ammo vs. The bottom line is that a pistol cartridge, even when fired from a carbine, is still going to perform like a pistol cartridge. Comparing the two in a head to head is easy when you’re only viewing the size of the caliber. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .223 Remington vs .30-06 Springfield ammo rounds. Presented for your consideration are M4 style carbines with 16-inch barrels. I have read the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy, and I hereby agree to those terms. Also, each carbine used a Picatinny rail gas block. Also, 9mm FMJ training ammunition costs about half the price of .223 FMJ training ammunition. But the throat length is short. However, if pricing is a serious concern, the 9mm Luger is likely your best choice. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. All external controls for both carbines were standard AR configuration, including the bolt catch, magazine release button, manual safety lever and trigger. My particular .380 carries 7 in the magazine, plus 1 “in the pipe,” i.e., a round already in the chamber. As for operation, the 5.56mm model was CMMG’s new gas-piston carbine and the 9mm version used a straight blowback, recoil-operated mechanism. A hole nearly three 3 inches across and as deep was left in the wax media. I have read the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy, and I hereby agree to those terms. .223 vs. 5.56 mm Ammo – a Comparison Many firearms novices, and even seasoned shooters, are unsure of the difference between .223 and 5.56 mm ammo. Both rounds easily passed through the basic wallboard material and then through the thicker wall and double 2×4 target. Both have flat-top receivers, 4-way rail aluminum forearms, and retractable stocks. Again, from 50 yards I fired several test groups on paper. Moving on, we found that the 9mm projectile had traveled a full 15 inches into the wax media after passing through the wall façade. Find out how your home-defense ammo stacks up against today’s criminal element. Training and target ammunition are great for the range, but when it really counts we need to spend the cash on high quality ammo designed for the task at hand. Consider that the torso on most human attackers will be anywhere from 10 to 15 inches, depending on the angle and human variables. It has energy of 1.770 Joules and a price per point of 30 cents per round. Both barrels were capped with a NATO-style birdcage flash suppressor. It had not deformed and looked almost good enough to be reloaded. When it comes to defending your life with a firearm, base your choices on fact, not supposition. Carbines or rifles are more imposing than handguns. Energy goes up/down proportionally with mass, but goes with the square of velocity. Both CMMG carbines that were tested use four-way aluminum rail systems. I reload both 223 and 5.56 cases with 27 grains of Hogdon CFE 223 powder for a 55 grain bullet and they both shoot well from my Remington 700 bolt action and my AR 15s . Rifle cartridges vs. handgun cartridges - a size comparison Rifle cartridges use more powder to propel their projectiles at much higher velocities than handgun bullets (the .30 caliber cartridges develop velocities in excess of 2,500 ft/sec, while most handgun bullets seldom exceed 1,700 ft/sec). For purposes of clarity, I consent to Athlon's collection, storage, processing, and transfer of my Personal Data and Non-Personal Data (as defined in the Privacy Policy) for the purpose of signing up for the email newsletter. Look up the . Featured herein would be their 60-grain TAP load chambered in .223 Remington. Hornady has been offering their TAP (Tactical Application Police) defensive line for some time now and it has seen success in real-world encounters. For the 9mm pistol ammunition side, the new Winchester PDX1 brand was tested. Over my chronograph, this load averaged 1,140 FPS from the 16-inch barrel. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet … The resulting groups were predictably tight. We Report, You Decide Both have flat-top receivers, 4-way rail aluminum forearms, and retractable stocks. A hole nearly three 3 inches across and as deep was left in the wax media. The projectile did its job very well and expanded violently. The throat angle is past 3 degrees.Meanwhile, a 5.56x45mm bullet has a .226 freebore diameter and .059-inch length. This ammunition line is specifically marketed for personal protection. In this video we are comparing Barnes TAC-XPD 9mm against Corbon Pow’RBall .45acp. The dual “circle and dot” reticle was used. Same scenario, shot through the wallboard into the wax media at 7 yards. Presented for your consideration are M4 style carbines with 16-inch barrels. Prudent homeowners understand that the best form of defense for…. Conclusion: 5.7x28mm vs 9mm Luger Either one of these cartridges will make a fantastic addition to your gun safe. After placing the wallboard material in front of the bullet trap, I took aim. CMMG, Inc. of Fayette, Missouri, happened to have a near matching set in both calibers. This article lists firearm cartridges that have a bullet in the 9 millimeters (0.35 in) to 9.99 millimeters (0.393 in) caliber range.Case length refers to the round case length. At that depth I discovered several bullet fragments. .380 vs 9mm: Recoil Among the most blatant arguments for the .380 ACP is the caliber is much milder. Presented for your consideration are M4 style carbines with sixteen inch barrels. When trouble comes through the door, the savvy homeowner is fully armed with the proper hardware, information, and self-defense training. The 7.62x39mm falls in between the two. This contraption was more of a rectangular trough made of wood with an open top. Surely the 9x19mm pistol cartridge would represent a reduced over-penetration hazard when compared to the .223 Remington centerfire rifle round. One model chambers the 5.56mm/.223 Remington round and the other … Prudent homeowners understand that the best form of defense for themselves and their families against assault is a firearm. The bottom line is that a pistol cartridge, even when fired from a carbine, is still going to perform like a pistol cartridge. Carbines or rifles are more imposing than handguns and send a stronger message. Secure some professional training and practice. The carbine platform has the advantage of being easier to control, aim, and hit your target with. Keep shooting straight and shooting safe. For this review it seemed logical to secure both a 9x19mm carbine and nearly identical version in .223 Remington. If this bullet looks familiar it is because the copper-colored projectile is the heart of Winchester’s Ranger LE ammunition line. An interior wall façade constructed of two layers of sheet rock and plywood. The Contenders Both have flat-top receivers, 4-way rail aluminum forearms, and retractable stocks. Metalform 32-round stick magazines fed the 9mm carbine. This barrier was built using two layers of half-inch sheet rock and a single layer of quarter-inch plywood. If this bullet looks familiar it is because the copper-colored projectile is the heart of Winchester’s Ranger LE ammunition line. Based upon our experiments, I believe we can see how this is not necessarily the case at all. CMMG, Inc. of Fayette, Missouri, happened to have a near matching set in both calibers. For this review it seemed logical to secure both a 9x19mm carbine and nearly identical version in .223 Remington. The 5.56 bullet has a throat angle at around 1 degree as well.There… However, on the other side, the results were a bit more spectacular. I needed to construct some realistic test barriers and bullet-capturing devices. Sizzle just waiting to be unleashed! Is this a serious question? What was most impressive was the fact that the .223 round deposited 100 percent of its energy into 8 inches of wax media. My 11 year old is proficent w/ a .223 at 200 yards. The smaller bullet size and higher speed of the 9mm mean that the firearm recoils less violently and has a significantly smaller amount of muzzle climb versus something like a 1911 in .45. This ammunition line is specifically marketed for personal protection. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .223 Remington vs .243 Winchester ammo rounds. We’ll also give you a breakdown of how we came to choose these picks. The free-floating 5.56mm barrel has 1 in 7 right hand twist rifling. Training and target ammunition are great for the range, but when it really counts we need to spend the cash on high quality ammo designed for the task at hand. As for our initial conversation, was the 9mm carbine less likely to “over-penetrate” than the .223? One model chambers the 5.56mm/.223 Remington round and the other the 9x19mm round. Presented for your consideration are M4 style carbines with 16-inch barrels. The best group was right at 1.25 inches. 9x19mm Also, it is a That’s twice the trigger time for the price. Dec 14, 2011, Stay in the know with the latest from the Tactical-Life newsletter, HEX Dragonfly: New Reflex Sight Runs on Pistols, Rifles & Shotguns, Cry Havoc GAU-5A: A Hands-On Look at the Air Force’s Backup Weapon, That Time a Trainee Dropped an M67 Frag Grenade in a Training Bunker, REPORT: Oakland Police Chief Wants Citizens to Stay Unarmed, Tactical Life Gun Magazine: Gun news, gun reviews and gun magazines for gun enthusiasts, military and law enforcement, You use of this website constitutes and manifests your acceptance of our. The projectile did its job very well and expanded violently. The projectile had come apart completely. The load in question was a 147-grain bonded JHP. Best self defense/personal protection ammo comparison. I needed to construct some realistic test barriers and bullet-capturing devices. Drywall Penetration: 9mm vs. 223 vs. 22 LR Russ Chastain 10.09.18 As you are probably aware, wall penetration is a common topic discussed by those who debate which round is … The bullet with the biggest diameter is one in .380". One model chambers the 5.56mm/.223 Remington round and the other the 9x19mm round. The Contenders Metalform 32-round stick magazines fed the 9mm carbine. The dual “circle and dot” reticle was used. This review is about much more than guns and ammo—it’s about performance. The 9mm is The free-floating 5.56mm barrel has 1 in 7 right hand twist rifling. The ammunition for this review would be that specifically designed from personal protection. It makes a world of sense. Navigate this article using… The twist rates vary from 1 in 10 to 1in 7 . The 9mm lower was a dedicated receiver, not a plugged or modified AR-type. An additional portion of the “wall” would include two 2×4 boards combined with the original sheet rock and plywood construction. 5.56 NATO/.223 Remington The range of bullet weights is actually much wider than what you might think, with the lightest being 17 grains like in a .17 HMR round and the heaviest being upward of 700 grains like for the .50 BMG cartridges . After placing the wallboard material in front of the bullet trap, I took aim. However neither caliber is magical, as some may believe. Specifically, he was worried about over-penetration. He was considering an AR carbine chambered in 9mm instead of .223. Both have flat-top receivers, 4-way rail aluminum forearms, and retractable stocks. For the above reasons, successful 9mm cast bullet loads are quite different from jacketed bullet loads and bullet fit is important to suc-cess. Kinetic energy is 1/2*m*v^2. One model chambers the 5.56mm/.223 Remington round and the other the 9x19mm round. The ammunition for this review would be that specifically designed from personal protection. A .223 case has the same diameter as a .380 case. If you own a 9mm handgun commonality of ammunition is a plus. Consider that the torso on most human attackers will be anywhere from 10 to 15 inches, depending on the angle and human variables. As for our initial conversation, was the 9mm carbine less likely to “over-penetrate” than the .223? He was considering an AR carbine chambered in 9mm instead of .223. When it comes to the issue of 9mm vs .45, obviously bullet placement and bullet construction is key for stopping an assailant. A .223 bullet is half the mass of a 9mm bullet, but goes almost 3x faster. On the front of the wallboard was an unimpressive .22 caliber hole. Typical .223 muzzle energy is about 1100 ft lbs. Many incorrectly assume that they are interchangeable, but they are, in fact, not interchangeable. A tight 1.17-inch three-shot cluster at 50 yards proved the carbine and ammo combination could be counted on. Arz [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons When looking at the .22LR vs .223, the truth is that the .223 is, in fact, a .22 caliber round.While the media loves to portray this as a ‘huge assault bullet’ and only meant for use in warfare, the truth is that a .223 round is a relatively small and not particularly powerful. To the casual reader this might seem like a very reasonable compromise. All of these are in inches, other than the 7.62mm, which is obviously in millimeters..308" and 7.62mm are the same diameter. It would seem that the purpose-designed .223 Remington load would be less likely to pass through an attacker and continue on through an interior wall than the 9mm fired from the same platform. The free-floating 5.56mm barrel has 1 in 7 right hand twist rifling. Caliber Type Bullet Diameter (In) Case Length (In).22LR Rimmed 0.223 0.613 25 ACP Semi-Rimmed 0.251 0.615.380 ACP Rimless 0.355 0.680 9mm Rimless 0.355 0.754.40 S&W Rimless 0.400 0.850.45 ACP Rimless 0.451 0.898 He had just about convinced himself to buy an AR platform carbine, but was having second thoughts about the .223 Remington cartridge and whether or not it was “safe” to use inside a home. That’s twice the trigger time for the price. Typical 9mm muzzle energy is about 400 ft lbs. 9mm vs. .40 caliber: How do the cartridges stack up? Both the 9mm and .223 Remington rounds passed completely through. First-time shooters and those with nerve The XPS3 uses only one CR123 Lithium battery and is more compact than older models. At that depth I discovered several bullet fragments. My goal in this review would be to compare the two from a ballistic standpoint, as well as provide a realistic downrange damage assessment. Over my chronograph, this load averaged 1,140 FPS from the 16-inch barrel. This barrier was built using two layers of half-inch sheet rock and a single layer of quarter-inch plywood. The bullet passed completely through and entered the waxy media. To the casual reader this might seem like a very reasonable compromise. It would seem that the purpose-designed .223 Remington load would be less likely to pass through an attacker and continue on through an interior wall than the 9mm fired from the same platform. Stock up here for LESS!. When it comes to defending your life with a firearm, base your choices on fact, not supposition. Note the mild fragmentation. .223 Remington. FREE GUN FRIDAY: Win a SIG Sauer Pistol and 9mm Ammo! From a distance of 7 yards, I fired a single round of the Winchester ammunition. These sights were zeroed a practical range of 50 yards. 9mm, well I have a Highpoint carbine, still like a BB gun. The carbine platform has the advantage of being easier to control, aim, and hit your target with. On the front of the wallboard was an unimpressive .22 caliber hole. Specifically, he was worried about over-penetration. This would represent a standard interior wall construction, minus 2×4 studs. 380 vs 9mm Stopping Power The penetration of the target, according to the FBI, is the most effective judgment of stopping an attacker in a self-defense situation. The 9mm and the .22LR are two popular ammunition out in the market. This contraption was more of a rectangular trough made of wood with an open top. The .223 is like a BB gun. Benching the rifle, once I had the EOTech optic properly zeroed, I put some test patterns downrange. With increasing pressure, fit in the barrel and forcing cone becomes progressively more important with cast bullets. Both rounds easily passed through the basic wallboard material and then through the thicker wall and double 2×4 target. .223" is roughly the equivalent of 5.56mm. The bullet passed completely through and entered the waxy media. Let’s start by looking at the size of the two options. A tight 1.17-inch three-shot cluster at 50 yards proved the carbine and ammo combination could be counted on. However, on the other side, the results were a bit more spectacular. Up first would be an interior wall façade. This would represent a standard interior wall construction, minus 2×4 studs. The 5.56 NATO/.223 Remington, left, is popular in AR-15s and modern sporting rifles while the 7.62 NATO/.308 Winchester, right is for AR-10s and classic battle rifles. I was privy to a conversation at a local gun shop where a man was pondering the purchase of a long gun for home protection. The free-floating 5.56mm barrel has 1 in 7 right hand twist rifling. The projectile had come apart completely. Smith & Wesson released the .40 S&W, and the new cartridge has gained traction, but the 9mm remains far more commonly used — here are some key differences The best group was right at 1.25 inches. You could make .380 cases out of .223, but the web would be too thick, resulting in reduced case capacity. When fired from my CMMG rifle, this loaded averaged 2,855 FPS (feet per second) over a Shooting Chrony F1 chronograph. For sights, I installed the new EOTech XPS3 HWS on each one. Entry holes: 9mm (upper left) and spectacular .223 wound cavity. .223 vs. .308 Bullet Trajectory Because it has a lighter bullet and faster speeds, the .223 Winchester usually maintains a flatter trajectory. Prudent homeowners understand that the best form of defense for themselves and their families…, by Paul Markel / I was privy to a conversation at a local gun shop where a man was pondering the purchase of a long gun for home protection. Next on the agenda was to fire both carbines into the 2×4 and wallboard material. Into the bullet box I place thick squares of waxy ballistic media. A .223 case is smaller in diameter than a 9mm case. Up first would be an interior wall façade. Capturing the fired bullets would be accomplished through the construction of a bullet trap of sorts. .223 Remington Tactical Life Gun Magazine: Gun News and Gun Reviews, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), DMR Battle: Daniel Defense DD5V3 vs. Rock River Arms BT-3 Precision, Red Arrow RAW15: Do-Everything Carbine Chambered in 5.56, Hatsan Blitz: .30 Caliber, Select-Fire Air Rifle Shoots Full-Auto, Stoeger M3500 Snow Goose: Purpose-Built Shotgun for Extreme Hunters, Sector Optics G1T2: The Do-It-All Scope You’ve Never Heard Of, Streamlight TLR-10: Rail-Mounted Weapon Light Pushes 1,000 Lumens, Night Vision 101: The Pros and Cons of Single-Tube vs Multi-Tube NODs, Team SIG’s Lena Miculek Makes History With Overall PCC Championship, Dead Reckoning: How Not Using a Compass Cost a Team Leader, Marines Officially Begin Use of New Squad Common Optic From Trijicon, WATCH: Vegas Police, Gun Range Workers Fatally Shoot Suspect, WATCH: Bay Area Officer Puts Down Armed Felon Who Goes for Gun, WATCH: Gas-Soaked, Barricaded Suspect Throws Molotov Cocktail at Police, WATCH: Range Time With the Primary Arms GLx 2.5-10×44 FFP Scope. For sights, I installed the new EOTech XPS3 HWS on each one. 9x19mm Parabellum (9mm NATO, 9mm Luger) is the most commonly used handgun caliber for defense among military forces, police, and civilians worldwide. 9mm It is officially known as the 9mm Luger or the 9x9mm Parabellum. Cutting Edge Bullets vs. … The throat length is also more than twice as great what the .223 uses. Mayor Bloomberg’s New York probe finds 62 percent of private gun sellers sell to prohibited individuals. These sights were zeroed a practical range of 50 yards. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet … The 9mm lower was a dedicated receiver, not a plugged or modified AR-type. Lower receivers varied in that the 5.56mm model used a standard AR configuration and was fed by all AR style magazines. The 9mm version used 1 in 10 rifling. For purposes of clarity, I consent to Athlon's collection, storage, processing, and transfer of my Personal Data and Non-Personal Data (as defined in the Privacy Policy) for the purpose of signing up for the email newsletter. From a practical, household standpoint, both platforms provide ample accuracy and few felons would want to be shot with either gun. This review is about much more than guns and ammo—it’s about performance. Based upon our range experiments, I believe we can see how this is not necessarily the case at all. This would represent nearly 6 inches of common building material found inside normal interior walls. For more fun at the range, or just plinking on the backlot, this bulk-buy .223 Ammo is ready to seal the deal. Its bullet weight is 55-62 grains and its speed is 3, 100 ft/s. One round of 9mm fired through a car door. An additional portion of the “wall” would include two 2×4 boards combined with the original sheet rock and plywood construction. Taking a moment to closely examine the bullet box, I pried apart the layers of wax media and found that the .223 TAP round had penetrated just shy of 8 inches. The XPS3 uses only one CR123 Lithium battery and is more compact than older models. For the 9mm pistol ammunition side, the new Winchester PDX1 brand was tested. The 9mm version used 1 in 10 rifling. It had not deformed and looked almost good enough to be reloaded. Presented for your consideration are M4 style carbines with 16-inch barrels. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Keep shooting straight and shooting safe. Benching the rifle, once I had the EOTech optic properly zeroed, I put some test patterns downrange. First up was the 9mm carbine. However neither caliber is magical, as some may believe. They are different in respect to cartridge sizes. The load in question was a 147-grain bonded JHP. Taking a moment to closely examine the bullet box, I pried apart the layers of wax media and found that the .223 TAP round had penetrated just shy of 8 inches. The resulting groups were predictably tight. We Report, You Decide Both of my youngest boys, the other is 14 shoot 6.5x55. Again, from 50 yards I fired several test groups on paper. Both the 9mm and .223 Remington rounds passed completely through. 5.7×28 is a pleasure to shoot and we admittedly had a good time with the Ruger 57. The ballistics are close to a 9mm Luger, just a less charge due to the 2mm shorter case length (9X19 vs 9X17). Both barrels were capped with a NATO-style birdcage flash suppressor. The .223 bullet in the 2,500 fps range will go through 1/4 inch steel plate, the 9mm, even in a longer barrel will hardly scratch 1/4 inch steel. He had just about convinced himself to buy an AR platform carbine, but was having second thoughts about the .223 Remington cartridge and whether or not it was “safe” to use inside a home. Next on the agenda was to fire both carbines into the 2×4 and wallboard material. Admittedly, 9mm handguns have the larger capacity with 15 to 17 rounds for regular full-size guns, with some guns like the Beretta which have 20 rounds in the magazine. Lower receivers varied in that the 5.56mm model used a standard AR configuration and was fed by all AR style magazines. FMJ for straight-shooting paper-punching power, priced to keep you firing all day! Secure some professional training and practice. For example, Federal Premium’s American Eagle 55-grain FMJ-BT cartridge, when zeroed to 100 yards, drops 2.7 inches after 200 yards. My goal in this review would be to compare the two from a ballistic standpoint, as well as provide a realistic downrange damage assessment. Same scenario, shot through the wallboard into the wax media at 7 yards. Ichiro Nagata Photo. All things considered, the .45 ACP is a bullet with a purpose. Before we completely discount the 9mm carbine, it does have some positive attributes. The .223 Remington bullet features a freebore diameter of .224 inches and a length of .025 inches. All external controls for both carbines were standard AR configuration, including the bolt catch, magazine release button, manual safety lever and trigger. Step two was to fire the .223 cartridge from Hornady. Capturing the fired bullets would be accomplished through the construction of a bullet trap of sorts. Surely the 9x19mm pistol cartridge would represent a reduced over-penetration hazard when compared to the .223 Remington centerfire rifle round.
Ncis'' High Tide Cast, Tilikum And Seaworld, Maglite Mini Pro, Grant's Golden Mole, Advan A048 Review, 1999 Volvo Semi Truck For Sale Craigslist, Bad Idea Cordae Lyrics, Islamic Dream Dog Poop,