The Heckler & Koch pistol featured good combat sights, each dovetailed in place in the slide. By Vic Laboy. For this, we’re looking at the Classic, which Walter brought back because of its popularity with shooters. It seemed a bit faster than the Walther in use. Other features include a smooth, 5.6-pound trigger pull, a Picatinny rail for mounting accessories, and front and rear serrations. Compare the dimensions and specs of Heckler & Koch VP9 and Walther PPQ M1 However, it was as handy or as inexpensive as having the two spare frame inserts supplied with the other handguns. The test gun came with the medium-grip full-size frame. The Walther PPQ’s features, accuracy and reliability all combine to make this gun one of the best on the market. Walther PPQ vs HK VP9: Features . vs. Kel-Tec . Both the VP9 and PPQ have Picatinny rails for lights, lasers, coffee makers and other accessories. A casual shooter might sign off on all three handguns, but that isn’t what we do. Comparison: SIG P320 vs. HK VP9. H&K VP9 = Best grip contour. We were able to use a Hidden Hybrid holster, designed as an IWB, but which has a belt slot for OWB use (HiddenHybridHolsters.com). HK claims this gun comes with a 5.4-pound trigger, which makes is just right for self defense. The sights were well regulated for 115-grain loads. The frame, magazine, and barrel are the same as the P250. This website contains many older reviews. This time, we decided to try another major debate in the gun world: the HK VP9 vs Walther PPQ. But I love my Kahr K40 also. PPQ M2 9mm 4" compare . They hold the same 15 rounds as the HK, but one of the Walther magazines featured a bumper pad or finger extension. Posted: 9/6/2015 5:33:22 PM EST ... HK VP9 vs Sig P320c vs Glock 19. These pistols are also both striker-fired guns, with paddle-style magazine releases and ambidextrous controls. The Sig p320 is garbage and has the egro's of a MAC-10. compare . This blog explores the reasons for the Walther PPQ's great trigger and explains why PPQ has such a short trigger reset. The KH VP9 is slightly larger, which accounts for it weighing just over 1 ounce more than the Walther PPQ. Compare the dimensions and specs of Heckler & Koch VP9 and Sig Sauer P320 XCompact. Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare ... Sig Sauer P320 XFull . VP9 Vs. PPQ, Sig 320, & Glock 17. In the HK, the Federal 147-grain HST +P went 1030 fps in the VP9 versus 1020 fps from the Walther. Each featured a polymer frame, a light rail, and similar sights. In the second entry of our 'Which Gun Would You Rather Have?' The Heckler & Koch pistol also featured a red cocking indicator. To the untrained eye, these two models appear identical; however, there are key differences that set one apart from the other. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), POF Minuteman: The 10.5-Inch Barreled 5.56mm NATO Pistol, Springfield Hellcat OSP: Carry Pistol Adds Manual Ambi-Safety, Lone Wolf LTD: Glock-Pattern G19-Sized Pistol for Concealed Carry, Blackhawk Stache: New IWB Holster Redefines Deep Concealment Gear, Bianchi Assent: Safariland’s Newest Concealment Holster Fits 250 Pistols, Winchester Defender Line Adds 5.56, 12-gauge & 20-gauge Loads, 82-Year-Old Vietnam Vet Beats Armed Intruder to Death With Shotgun Butt, 12-Year-Old Boy Grabs Gun, Shoots Intruders Who Shot His Grandmother, WATCH: Texas Mom Lays Out Alleged Peeper With Bone-Crushing Tackle, Taurus TX 22 Competition: Red Dot Mounts Directly to New Pistol’s Barrel, Federal Releases Hydra-Shok Component Bullets for Handloaders. Our shooters noticed the trigger actions were markedly different, and grip texturing and handling were considerably different. P320 X-Carry . The compact 9mm P320 has the same magazine capacity as the HK VP9 (15 rounds) but the capacity of the P320 can easily be increased to 17 rounds by using a longer full-size P320 mag in it, or buying the "carry" model grip module and magazine(s). The trigger only releases the striker, which is different from many striker-fired pistols, making it virtually a single-action pistol. Shooters can also customize the grip via one of three interchangeable backstraps. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete. The pistol’s low bore axis resulted in little muzzle flip. Our Team Said: The Heckler & Koch VP9 9mm has the best combination of features for personal defense in this trio. 92X Compact . vs. Beretta . Prior to range testing, we field-stripped the SIG. The P99 also features a decocker button to put the pistol back to the double action pull. While not service grade, the holster was an aid on the range. In the last poll — SIG P320 vs Glock 19 — the Glock 19 has a narrow edge over the SIG P320 after nearly 5,500 votes. Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; ... Walther . Now the VP9 doesn’t come with a manual safety. Well, in truth, I don't want a 5.6# trigger whether it be Walther or HK. Also the ergonomics of the VP9 has many favoring the feel of the VP in their hands. There are simply more possibilities for fine tuning hand-to-gun fit with the other makes, we believe. Well, there it is. The pistol breaks down differently, however, by using two levers in front of the trigger guard. Even so, the Walther was the least expensive handgun tested. The SIG weighs 29.5 ounces unloaded, making it the heaviest handgun tested. In Ruger's case, removing the mag disconnect, polishing internal contact surfaces and adding a $20 - $27 trigger bar reset, depending on model, will get you a trigger pull at 4# or less. VP9 . While some raters were neutral on this feature, others did not like this. The SIG demonstrated the highest velocity with the Federal American Eagle load and the Federal 147-grain HST +P load used in accuracy work. Now all you have to do is vote. The Walther PPQ is available in a couple of versions — the PPQ Classic and PPQ M2. With the changeable backstraps it is hard to imagine that the PPQ would not fit 95 percent of shooters just fine. Compare the dimensions and specs of Heckler & Koch VP9 and Sig Sauer P226 Full Size The Walther shot well in combat drills, but all commented that the PPQ M2 exhibited the hardest felt recoil. That being said, both of these German feats of firearm engineering feature incredible intuitive controls and excellent customization abilities. The slide had a Nitron finish and forward cocking serrations. The gun’s low-profile, three-dot polymer sights allow rapid target acquisition without snagging clothing. The pistol came with two magazines, both well made. Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; ... Sig Sauer . Also, the trigger wasn’t ideal for personal defense. With that said, here are the tales of the tape regarding the Walther PPQ and the H&k VP9. This was most noticeable with the Federal 147-grain HST +P loading. Of course, the additional weight is negligible, and both come with 15, plus one in the chamber, capacity. The sole bone of contention was the magazine release. Anyone choosing the HK will be able to quickly acclimate to the magazine latch, we feel, and there are no drawbacks to its operation. PPQ M2 9mm 4" compare . With the other handguns, we were scraping to find a holster during the test period. At first glance, the handguns appeared similar. ... PPQ M2 have better triggers that the P320 That being said, the P320 doesn’t have a bad trigger, I just prefer the VP9 and the PPQ. The SIG was supplied with two magazines and a plastic range holster. Field strip was simple enough, using a takedown lever. We found the trigger to be controllable, and it offered good combat accuracy. The Walther PPQ had received great reviews and a keen following as the great successor of the already solid P99 pistol. The trigger action, sights, the grip frame’s range of adjustment, and the feel going to and engaging targets make it the best gun in this test, we believe. Disclaimer-I own the HK and one of the other shooters owned the Sig P320, The third shooter was undecided on which to buy. We used Federal American Eagle 115-grain FMJ ammunition for our familiarization runs because it’s affordable ($14.49/50 at MidwayUSA.com). All raters said that it felt lighter than it actually registered on the trigger gauge. We changed the grip inserts back and forth more with this handgun than the Walther, and found it offers a good range of hand fit. Testing and Ranking 5 Subcompact 9mm Pistols on the Range. The HK VP9 is the company’s latest striker-fired pistol. During the past few months, SIG Sauer, Walther, and Heckler & Koch have introduced pistols that feature striker-fired actions. The sights were different, but usable. The HK is much different, with a paddle-type release. None had a manual safety as part of the design. The trigger was pleasant, and light and smooth enough at 6.0 pounds. Its polymer frame comes with three interchangeable backstraps, as well as side panels in small, medium and large. The same can be said for the Glock by using a G 17 magazine and the G 19. In absolute accuracy, the pistol was limited by the heavy trigger but exhibited an average group size of 2.2 inches at 15 yards with the most accurate load, the Hornady 115-grain XTP. The Walther uses a reversible button-style mag release. In firing during combat drills, the HK generated more felt recoil than the SIG, but it wasn’t uncomfortable, and it was more comfortable to fire than the Walther. _____ July 06, 2019, 06:49 AM. ... Heckler & Koch . The frame was stippled in a crescent pattern on both the front and rear straps and the sides. The grip frame was roughened for adhesion similar to the HK. They may be removed if desired. Once you spend some time behind the VP9 or better yet the PPQ Match5 triggers, you are finding a whole other realm of trigger and hand gun. This striker-fired pistol comes with a 4-inch barrel and an overall length of 7.1 inches. It also comes with an ambidextrous paddle-style magazine release and slide stop. It seems that American shoote… The P320's modularity is good for someone who wants literally the same exact trigger in different size frames and calibers. In the last poll — SIG P320 vs Glock 19 — the Glock 19 has a narrow edge over the SIG P320 after nearly 5,500 votes. It shot the tightest group, a 1.7-inch cluster fired with the Hornady 115-grain XTP. The Heckler & Koch pistol features grip inserts and also side panels, which we rate above the other handguns for versatility. These 9mm pistols are similar, but each contains a different feel, especially to strong-mined shooters. VP9 or second G19. Subjectively, I thought the VP9 was the nicest shooting of the three. compare . P320 XCompact . Compare the dimensions and specs of Heckler & Koch VP9 and Sig Sauer P320 XFull. The improvement in rapid-fire combat shooting is provable, and absolute accuracy is improved over the original SIG P250, Walther P99 and HK P30. The Walther was supplied with two magazines. It features ambidextrous controls with a magazine release unfamiliar to most American shooters. H&K VP9 Vs. Walther PPQ M2. As you are all aware the VP9 and P320 are new striker fired polymer pistols, they are new entries into the market place, I can say both Sig and HK did their homework on these 2 pistols. The SIG magazine release was a trapezoidal shape. The P320 seems quite heavy for a plastic gun, but the grip is the usual SiG-low. Written and photographed by R.K. Campbell, using evaluations from Gun Tests team testers. HK VP9 vs Walther PPQ. By introducing the VP70, HK became the first manufacturer to introduce a polymer-framed, striker-fired pistol to the market. I've also gone back & forth between a 320FS and VP9 for a while. Posted: 9/6/2015 5:31:35 PM EST Walther PPQ M1. ARCHIVED; compare . Though the flip… My PPQ always goes with me to the range along with one of my SIG P226s and my HK P30LS. The grip frame and magazines are identical. There were no finger grooves. The pistol’s grip frame fit most hands well, and we found the grip texture to be particularly good. Its Tenifer coating on the slide and barrel provides a matte finish, along with corrosion resistance. May 16, 2019, Stay in the know with the Personal Defense World newsletter, Hellcat RDP: Springfield Unveils New HEX Wasp Red Dot Atop New Pistol, WATCH: Retired Chicago Fireman, Concealed Carrier Killed in Carjacking, Rep. Carolyn Maloney Drops the Mother of All Gun Control Bills, NICS Review Act: Maloney’s Bill Would Weaponize the NICS System, Gun News, Gun Reviews, and Self Defense Tips, You use of this website constitutes and manifests your acceptance of our. Not exactly a bantamweight fighter, the VP9SK has roots going back to the beginning of the polymer pistol era. This means shooters can adjust front-to-rear length, shape and even palm swell width. Unless otherwise noted, these reviews carry the guns’ prices at the time of the original review. It was a reliable handgun. While the P99 was striker fired, it was unique in that the first trigger pull is long while all subsequent shots are short. It even comes with either luminescent three-dot sights or Meprolight tritium night sights, which cost a little extra, as well as front and rear serrations and an accessory rail. Now, it is up to you, the reader, to tell us which you would prefer. We had the impression of pressing forward as well as in with this release. Walther . HK Produces the VP9 in black, FDE, OD Green, and grey. vs. Sig Sauer . compare . The PPQ is simply an updated version of their previous P99 series of pistols. Shot a new poly PPQ Match5 at the range today and I just got to get one. Trigger compression was con-sistent at 7.75 pounds, the heaviest of the three handguns tested. HK VP9 vs Sig P320 vs Walther PPQ – Ultimate Striker Fired Pistol Gunminded December 6, 2015 23:30 Another good shootout and comparison video with these three striker fired newcomers. Each was a steel unit with the popular 3-white-dot design. The other handguns did not fire high. A quick search found grip modules at SelwayArmory.com for $40. Walther PPQ = Best trigger/reset. Manufacturer: Sig Sauer. The pistol featured an ambidextrous slide lock that worked well in practice for easy use by right- or left-handed shooters. Polymer-Frame 9mm Shoot Out: P320 Versus PPQ M2 Vs. VP9, Smith & Wesson Performance Center Model 986, Springfield Armory XD-M Tactical 45 Review, The Bolt-Action Handy Rifle in 2021: Savage 110 Hog Hunter, 380 ACP Ammunition Testing: Bullet Development Continues, Twelve 22 Long Rifle Cartridges, Shot From a Rifle This Round, 9mm Barrel Lengths Compared In Range Performance Testing, 12-Gauge Mini Shells from Federal, Aguila, and Nobel, Gun Belts: Beat the Sag with Choices from Wright, Bigfoot, Quick-Release Extended Scope Mounts For Carbines & Rifles, BATFE Reclassifies ‘Honey Badger’ AR Pistols as SBRs, PROOF Research Introduces the $8500 Conviction Ti Long-Range Precision Tactical Rifle, Ruger GP-100 .357 Magnum No. Disclaimer-I own the HK and one of the other shooters owned the Sig P320, The third shooter was undecided on which to buy. The P320 also wasn’t as friendly to diverse hand sizes as were the other guns. CP33 . However, there were no inadvertent magazine-release incidents. The SIG P320 was rated the most comfortable to fire, as far as recoil goes. The pistol came with white grease on the rails, so we did not lubricate it further. However, in addition to finger grooves on the front strap, this pistol also featured raised areas on each side of the grip. On top, the slide was thinner, and the HK pistol featured forward cocking serrations and well defined rear cocking serrations on the slide. Polymer-Frame 9mm Shoot Out: P320 Versus PPQ M2 Vs. VP9. There was no creep or backlash. While it didn’t exactly check all the boxes at the time, HK has come full circle with other polymer models such as the VP9SK to try to perfect the modern striker-fire… The SIG sights were dovetailed into place front and rear, as were the HK’s sights. There were grooves in the handle to allow a strong grasp on the magazine in the event it got stuck. While it featured the lightest texture of the three handguns, it worked OK in helping us hold the gun. They were not mounted in dovetail slots in the manner of the other handguns we tested. Trigger travel was about 0.4 inch, and we thought the reset was fast. In fact, both barrels measure right around 4 inches, with overall lengths of a little more than 7 inches. For purposes of clarity, I consent to Athlon's collection, storage, processing, and transfer of my Personal Data and Non-Personal Data (as defined in the Privacy Policy) for the purpose of signing up for the email newsletter. The front was a post, and the rear, interestingly, was adjustable for windage with a set screw. This time, we decided to try another major debate in the gun world: the HK VP9 vs Walther PPQ. The first gun that the HK VP reminded me of was the Walther PPQ mostly due to their similar, outstanding triggers. This grip frame seemed to suit the raters across the board. The HK VP9 features a striker-fired action, in contrast to the original double-action hammer-fired HK P30. This was the largest grip of the three handguns. The HK pistol also comes with side panels to modify the grip. The Walther PPQis slightly older than the VP9, being released in 2011. The Heckler & Koch VP9 is based on the HK P30 pistol. After 30 years of only being available in loaded rounds, Hydra-Shok component bullets are... by Personal Defense World / The question is, which handgun is the most improved and the best buy for the money — that is, the most reliable and accurate? P320 M18 . That said, let's get into the VP9 vs. Sig P320. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! When working with this trigger, one of our raters came straight off the SIG and its 7.75-pound trigger. You’ll recall that in the October 2020 issue, I cut-and-pasted almost all of then-presidential candidate Joe Biden’s gun-regulation plans listed on his website, with... Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. Striker-fired pistols that also use a manual safety will give a lighter trigger. The grip frame may also be exchanged for larger or smaller units. During the testing, the 147-grain load fired high, which was expected, but the 115-grain +P load also fired high, as did the generic 115-grain ball load. During combat drills, the pistol performed well. But the SIG trigger doesn’t have a safety lever, so it would not be wise to offer a lighter trigger without re-engineering it. As you are all aware the VP9 and P320 are new striker fired polymer pistols, they are new entries into the market place, I can say both Sig and HK did their homework on these 2 pistols. In this test of three 9mm striker-fired models, we were firing handguns intended for personal defense in the home, concealed carry, and practical competition. VP9 carry's better (a mild +), but the 320 is a tack driver, little recoil, and is used for competition (regular P320 FS which has been played w/: GG curved trigger, internals, Springer tungsten rod, spring, X5 grip with the full weight, no mag tunnel - and I will admit to having a 320 addiction: all the X5 320 models … But our shooters liked the Heckler & Koch the best. The smallest size and the thinnest panels would be indicated for personal defense and concealed carry use. Gun Tests has been independently reviewing firearms since 1989. There was no lever in the trigger to prevent lateral discharge. These handguns are designed to compete for the hearts and minds of institutional buyers and concealed-carry-permit holsters as well. It was ambidextrous, but functioned differently from the Browning push button we are used to. PPQ Q4 Tac M2 . The rest of the team rated it even with the others. The trigger is OK for a service pistol, but most of us would like a lighter trigger for better accuracy. The pressure required to activate this release is lighter than the SIG. We prefer the dovetail. This time, we decided to try another major debate in the gun world: the HK VP9 vs Walther PPQ. VP9 Is A People's Pistol For The 21st Century The VP9 by Heckler and Koch - VP stands for "Volkspistole" or "People's Pistol" - is one of the better-regarded striker pistols, widely regarded for a good trigger, outstanding accuracy and easy shooting dynamics. The Walther was similar to the other handguns in that it featured forward cocking serrations and a light rail. The dots were green in bright light and gave excellent contrast when firing for accuracy.